The Pittsburgh Steelers' quarterback situation, a constant topic of discussion, has entered a new phase of uncertainty and evaluation following the expiration of Aaron Rodgers' one-year contract. Rodgers, who led a game-winning drive in Week 18 to clinch the AFC North title, is now set for free agency, leaving the Steelers with two passers under contract for the 2026 season: veteran Mason Rudolph and 2025 sixth-round selection Will Howard.
New head coach Mike McCarthy has provided initial insight into his evaluation of the holdovers. Reports indicate that McCarthy likes the potential he sees in Will Howard, who spent his rookie 2025 season developing within the system. Furthermore, McCarthy has expressed a belief that Mason Rudolph "can be a contributor." Rudolph, who has spent multiple seasons with the Steelers in various backup roles, provides experienced depth. This internal assessment suggests the team may not feel compelled to make a panic move in the quarterback market, though all options remain on the table.
This developing picture sets the stage for a critical offseason decision. The Steelers possess significant cap space—roughly $65.4 million—which provides flexibility. The organization could pursue a veteran free agent, explore the trade market, or use a high draft pick to add competition. McCarthy's offensive system and his comfort level with Howard and Rudolph will be major factors. The decision at quarterback will be the most defining one for the McCarthy era's inaugural season, as the team aims to build on a 2025 division title and find an answer to their prolonged postseason struggles.