The narrative surrounding Bryce Young has undergone a dramatic transformation. Just two years ago, critics debated whether the undersized Alabama product could anchor an NFL franchise. Now, in May 2026, the conversation has shifted decisively. NBC Sports analyst Chris Simms released his annual 2026 quarterback countdown on May 22, placing the Carolina Panthers' signal-caller among the NFL's elite. This ranking validates the Panthers organization's conviction when they traded up to select Young first overall in the 2023 NFL Draft.
Simms' video analysis breaks down Young's game, development, and outlook entering his fourth NFL season. While Simms' rankings often spark debate -- known for zigging when others zag -- Young's placement in the top tier of quarterbacks is no longer a hot take. It reflects the evident progress on film and results on the field.
From Doubt to Recognition
It's important to remember where Young stood as recently as 18 months ago. After a difficult rookie season marked by coaching upheaval and a less-than-ideal supporting cast, skepticism was rampant. Questions abounded about his size, durability, and ability to process NFL defenses quickly enough to succeed.
The 2024 season began to quiet these doubts, but it was the 2025 campaign that truly silenced critics. Under Head Coach Dave Canales and Offensive Coordinator Brad Idzik, Young led the Panthers to an NFC South championship -- the franchise's first playoff berth since 2017. He displayed precision, poise, and an increasingly nuanced understanding of Carolina's offense, making the team a dangerous opponent in clutch moments.
The Panthers' decision to exercise Young's fifth-year option this offseason was largely procedural. The real statement came through his performance. Young completed 66.8% of his passes in 2025, throwing 28 touchdowns against just 9 interceptions, while orchestrating a scoring offense ranked in the league's upper half. His ability to extend plays and identify secondary receivers kept drives alive, a skill that the less mature version of Young might not have possessed.
What Chris Simms Observed
Simms' ranking is respected for its foresight. He was an early advocate for Josh Allen and Patrick Mahomes, and now places Young in similarly esteemed company. Simms focused on several key improvements: Young's faster processing speed, his ability to diagnose coverage post-snap, and his vastly improved ball placement on intermediate routes.
These observations harmonize with what Panthers fans witnessed during the 2025 season. Early in his career, Young often checked down prematurely or delayed throws waiting for routes to develop. By 2025, he was threading accurate passes into tight windows on critical third downs, displaying confidence in his arm and receivers. This was aided by the Panthers' offensive line, anchored by tackles Ikem Ekwonu and Taylor Moton, which provided cleaner pockets and time to make plays.
Further bolstering the offense, the receiving corps was entirely revamped. second-year wide receiver Tetairoa McMillan introduced a dynamic downfield threat, while Xavier Legette and Jalen Coker served as reliable chain-movers. Tight end Ja'Tavion Sanders emerged as a mismatch nightmare in the middle, giving Young a dependable safety valve capable of turning short receptions into significant gains. This group represents a stark upgrade from the 2023 unit, which was undermined by dropped passes and route mistakes.
The Bigger Picture
Where Young lands in Simms' overall rankings is significant. While the full list is released gradually, Young's inclusion in the upper echelon signals that Simms sees him as not just a competent manager but a quarterback capable of winning games. This marks a departure from earlier narratives labeling Young as a "system QB" or mere "game manager."
The NFC South landscape itself has evolved. With Tom Brady retired, the division has returned to a more open competition. The Falcons, Saints, and Buccaneers all face questions at quarterback, while Carolina boasts clarity with Young as their established franchise signal-caller continually improving.
This trajectory is perhaps more crucial than Young's precise ranking. Simms' list is a snapshot moment; development is an ongoing process. Young's leap from rookie struggles to competent starter was notable, and his progression from Year 2 to Year 3 was substantial. Should his upward trend continue, he will be viewed not only as a top 10 QB but also as a potential MVP contender by 2027.
A Growing Supporting Cast
Young's success is supported by an aggressive front office strategy led by General Manager Dan Morgan. The Panthers' running back room now features Chuba Hubbard as a steady, reliable presence alongside young talents Jonathon Brooks and Trevor Etienne, a three-headed backfield that keeps defenses honest and eases pressure on Young.
Defensively, Carolina added pass-rushing talent like Jaelan Phillips and Nic Scourton to complement the interior strength of Derrick Brown. The secondary, with stars Jaycee Horn and Tre'von Moehrig, helps the offense by forcing turnovers and generating better field position. The special teams unit remains anchored by veteran long snapper JJ Jansen, providing stability and consistently favorable field position.
With a balanced running game, a stout defense, and solid special teams, the margin for error for Young widens. He doesn't need perfection every week -- just consistent, effective play, which he delivered in 2025.
Looking Ahead to 2026
The upcoming season poses a test of sustainability. Can Young maintain or improve upon his 2025 performance now that opposing defenses have a full offseason to study and gameplan against him? Can he shoulder the expectations as a division champion and established top-tier NFL quarterback?
Based on all available evidence, the answer is yes. Young's work ethic is widely praised; he is known for long hours and intense preparation, demanding the same from his teammates. His leadership has matured, earning the trust of his locker room, which is evident in critical late-game moments where the outcome hangs in the balance.
While Simms' ranking serves as valuable external validation, the Panthers' goals extend beyond individual accolades. The organization is focused on sustained success: multiple division titles, playoff runs, and ultimately, a Super Bowl championship. Bryce Young is clearly the focal point of that ambition.
For Panthers fans, the era of uncertainty about their franchise quarterback is over. Chris Simms' countdown only confirms what the Charlotte faithful already knew: Bryce Young is a franchise quarterback with a promising future, and the best is yet to come.