Schedule →
PFNN NFL Pick’em leaguePick every game. Free. · Free to play · Climb the leaderboard · Earn bragging rightsPlay for free →

Colts Roundup: Alec Pierce, Drake Maye, and Quinshon Judkins Shine in 2026

By Pro Football News Network3 min readIndianapolis Colts
Share:
PFNN NFL Pick’em leaguePick every game. Free. · Free to play · Climb the leaderboard · Earn bragging rightsPlay for free →

Four stories, one mood: somebody is going to have to be patient. The Colts have no choice about it. Two young offensive players get to decide what they do with it. And anyone setting a fantasy lineup this week just has to make seven calls and stop pretending to feel great about them.

Start in Indianapolis, where ESPN reports the Colts are placing top wide receiver Alec Pierce on injured reserve with a heel injury. This is the item on today's board I can't dress up. Losing your top receiver to IR isn't a depth-chart inconvenience, it's a structural problem — an IR stint is not a one-week parking job, and a passing game has to be rebuilt around the absence. What I'll give you for the Colts: IR at least creates clarity a week-to-week designation never does. The next man up knows the job is his for a while, and offenses sometimes get more efficient when the quarterback stops hunting one target. That's the optimistic case, and it is a case, not a promise. It also reshuffles fantasy value across that entire receiving room, so if you're starting a Colt pass-catcher this week, redo the math.

Which is the perfect on-ramp to ESPN's start-sit piece: seven decisions you're dreading in Week 3, with Loza laying out facts so you can decide whether the borderline guys are truly borderline. I love the framing, because facts versus feelings is the whole game. My read, and I'll commit to it: when the facts and your gut disagree about a flex, the facts usually win. Your gut is remembering last week. The facts are describing the job. Seven dread decisions is a lot of dread for one week, which tells you something about how unsettled the league's skill positions are right now. Use the piece — just don't use it to talk yourself into a player you already know is a trap.

Then there's Drake Maye. Field Yates is expecting him to bounce back in Week 3, and I'm siding with it. An expectation like that is a claim about process, not a projected stat line — it means the people watching think the errors were correctable rather than structural. Analysts hedge when the problems look like they live in the scheme or the supporting cast. Yates didn't hedge. That's the version of this story I'd bet on, and Maye is the player on today's board with the most room to move up.

The funnier question belongs to Quinshon Judkins: can he turn things around in Week 3? Here's my honest position, and it isn't a sunny one — the fact that we're asking in Week 3 is itself the headline. But there's real opportunity inside a slow start. A back who's searching tends to keep getting fed while a staff tries to fix it, and if the answer is yes this week, the payoff lands before the market catches up. That's the case for buying low, not a guarantee he rewards it.

So: Indianapolis gets worse and clearer at the same time, Maye gets a week to prove the tape was right, Judkins gets a week to prove the question was premature, and the rest of us get seven decisions to get wrong. The Colts' receiving room are the clear losers of the day. Maye and Judkins are the two players with the most to gain this weekend — and if you're setting a lineup, that's where I'd spend my attention.

PFNN NFL Pick’em Against the Spread league
NFL Pick’em 2026 - Against the Spread
Straight up is easy. Try it against the spread.
Every game, every line · Free to play · Weekly leaderboard
Take the spread →

Researched and drafted with Pro Football News Network's AI reporting system and reviewed under human editorial oversight.

Share: